| Ohio Northern |
14-3 |
31-12 |
| John Carroll |
12-6 |
31-15 |
| Otterbein |
11-7 |
26-16 |
| Muskingum |
10-8 |
23-17 |
| Mount Union |
10-8 |
21-20 |
| Marietta |
8-10 |
20-18 |
| Capital |
6-10 |
21-17 |
| Heidelberg |
6-11 |
19-18 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
6-12 |
18-20 |
| Wilmington |
5-13 |
16-24 |
| Marietta |
16-2 |
38-6 |
| Mount Union |
13-5 |
28-15 |
| Heidelberg |
11-7 |
27-17 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
9-9 |
27-13 |
| Muskingum |
9-9 |
18-21 |
| John Carroll |
9-9 |
18-22 |
| Otterbein |
8-10 |
22-17 |
| Ohio Northern |
7-10 |
15-23 |
| Capital |
4-13 |
15-22 |
| Wilmington |
3-15 |
7-27 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
9-0 |
29-1 |
| Ohio Northern |
8-1 |
12-6 |
| Otterbein |
7-2 |
10-11 |
| Mount Union |
6-3 |
13-8 |
| John Carroll |
5-4 |
8-12 |
| Heidelberg |
4-5 |
9-8 |
| Capital |
3-6 |
7-19 |
| Marietta |
2-7 |
7-9 |
| Muskingum |
1-8 |
4-9 |
| Wilmington |
0-9 |
0-12 |
| Ohio Northern |
8-0 |
23-5 |
| John Carroll |
7-1 |
14-4 |
| Otterbein |
6-2 |
10-10 |
| Mount Union |
5-3 |
13-7 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
4-4 |
9-14 |
| Heidelberg |
3-5 |
5-8 |
| Capital |
2-6 |
3-16 |
| Muskingum |
1-7 |
4-10 |
| Wilmington |
0-0 |
1-1 |
| Marietta |
0-8 |
1-12 |
| Mount Union |
9-0 |
14-1 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
7-2 |
8-2 |
| Heidelberg |
7-2 |
8-2 |
| Ohio Northern |
5-4 |
6-4 |
| Capital |
5-4 |
5-5 |
| John Carroll |
5-4 |
5-5 |
| Muskingum |
3-6 |
4-6 |
| Marietta |
2-7 |
3-7 |
| Otterbein |
2-7 |
3-7 |
| Wilmington |
0-9 |
0-10 |
| Ohio Northern |
8-0-1 |
20-3-2 |
| John Carroll |
7-2 |
12-8 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
6-3 |
16-6 |
| Wilmington |
5-4 |
11-7-1 |
| Mount Union |
4-3-2 |
10-8-2 |
| Capital |
4-4-1 |
9-9-1 |
| Otterbein |
3-6 |
5-10-2 |
| Muskingum |
2-6-1 |
7-11-1 |
| Marietta |
1-6-2 |
2-13-2 |
| Heidelberg |
1-7-1 |
3-11-4 |
| Ohio Northern |
9-0 |
16-3-2 |
| Otterbein |
7-1-1 |
10-6-2 |
| Capital |
7-1-1 |
13-8-2 |
| John Carroll |
6-3 |
14-8 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
4-5 |
11-9 |
| Wilmington |
4-5 |
6-11-3 |
| Mount Union |
3-6 |
8-9-2 |
| Heidelberg |
3-6 |
6-11-1 |
| Muskingum |
1-8 |
5-14 |
| Marietta |
0-9 |
1-16-1 |
| Heidelberg |
9-0 |
32-7 |
| Otterbein |
8-1 |
25-6 |
| Mount Union |
7-2 |
25-8 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
5-4 |
18-13 |
| Ohio Northern |
5-4 |
14-16 |
| Capital |
4-5 |
20-12 |
| Marietta |
4-5 |
14-15 |
| Muskingum |
2-7 |
12-16 |
| Wilmington |
1-8 |
13-17 |
| John Carroll |
0-9 |
9-17 |
| John Carroll |
13-5 |
18-7 |
| Capital |
13-5 |
19-10 |
| Marietta |
12-6 |
17-9 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
11-7 |
16-10 |
| Wilmington |
10-8 |
15-13 |
| Ohio Northern |
8-10 |
14-14 |
| Mount Union |
7-11 |
11-15 |
| Otterbein |
6-12 |
9-17 |
| Muskingum |
5-13 |
8-17 |
| Heidelberg |
5-13 |
7-18 |
| Mount Union |
17-1 |
28-2 |
| Ohio Northern |
14-4 |
21-6 |
| Otterbein |
13-5 |
20-7 |
| Capital |
12-6 |
18-9 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
11-7 |
17-10 |
| Wilmington |
7-11 |
13-14 |
| John Carroll |
6-12 |
9-16 |
| Marietta |
5-13 |
10-16 |
| Muskingum |
4-14 |
9-16 |
| Heidelberg |
1-17 |
4-21 |
